Should You Repair or Replace Your Broken Stove? Let’s Break It Down

Your stove isn’t working right—and now you’re stuck wondering, “Do I fix it, or just get a new one?” That’s a pretty common question. And the truth is, it depends on a few simple things, like how old your stove is, what’s wrong with it, and whether a repair would actually save you money in the long run. In this guide, we’ll walk you through everything you need to know to make the best choice—without all the confusing terms or pressure. Let’s get into it.

How Do You Know If Your Stove Can Be Repaired?

A lot of stove issues are minor and totally fixable. If your burners won’t light or your oven won’t heat evenly, that doesn’t mean the whole thing is shot.

Common Small Problems That Can Be Fixed:

• Burners not turning on
• Oven taking too long to heat up
• Clicking sounds from a gas stove
• Dials or knobs not working right
• Electric burner not heating

If your stove isn’t too old and this is the first time something’s gone wrong, there’s a good chance a repair is all you need. And most of these fixes don’t take long or cost too much.

When It’s Probably Time for a New Stove

Sometimes, fixing the stove just isn’t worth it—especially if the same things keep going wrong or it’s older than your favorite hoodie.

Signs You Might Want to Replace It:

• It’s 15 years old (or more)
• You’ve already paid for multiple repairs
• Fixing it will cost almost as much as a new one
• It doesn’t cook evenly or heat up right
• It looks worn out and runs up your energy bill

If your stove is old and unreliable, you could be spending more fixing it over time than just getting a new one that works better and uses less energy.

Let’s Talk Cost: Fixing vs. Replacing

Money matters—no doubt about that. So let’s keep it real about the numbers.

• Repairing a stove: Usually costs between $100 and $300 depending on what’s wrong
• Replacing a stove: New ones usually run from $500 to $2,000, plus installation

If your repair is simple and affordable, go for it. But if fixing it is half the cost of a new one—or more—you’re probably better off upgrading.

How Long Do Stoves Usually Last?

Stoves aren’t forever, even if they’ve been part of your kitchen for years.

• Gas stoves usually last about 13 to 17 years
• Electric stoves usually make 11 to 15 years

So if yours is creeping up on 15 and giving you problems, that might be your stove’s way of saying, “Hey, I’m done.” Old Stoves vs. New Ones: What’s the Difference? Newer stoves do more than just look nice. They cook better, use less energy, and usually come with safety features you didn’t know you needed.

Perks of a Newer Stove:

• Heats up faster and more evenly
• Safer with auto shut-off features
• Uses less gas or electricity
• Helps lower your monthly energy bills
• Looks great in your kitchen

So if you’re cooking a lot or just tired of dealing with the old one, getting something new could be a smart move—not just a shiny one.

Should You Try to Fix It Yourself?

Some little things you can check yourself, like cleaning a burner or resetting a breaker. But once wires, gas, or electric parts are involved—call a pro.

When It’s Best to Call a Technician:

• You smell gas
• The stove keeps turning off or tripping your breaker
• There’s sparking or smoke
• You need to swap out real parts (not just knobs)

Safety first, always. It’s not worth saving a few bucks if it risks your home or health.

How to Pick the Right Repair Service

Whether you decide to fix or replace it, working with the right company matters. You want someone honest, skilled, and easy to reach. What to Look For:

• Fast service (same day or next day is best)
• Clear prices with no surprise charges
• Friendly and experienced technicians
• Reviews from happy local customers

Always check their reviews and ask questions. A good company will walk you through your options and won’t push you into something you don’t need.

So, What’s the Right Call? Repair or Replace?

Here’s the simple version:

• If your stove is still fairly new and just has a small issue, go ahead and repair it.
• If it’s old, causing frequent problems, or expensive to fix, it’s probably time for a new one.

No need to guess—just have a pro take a look. They’ll tell you what’s wrong, how much it’ll cost, and whether it’s worth fixing. FAQs—Quick Answers to Common Questions Q: How much does a stove repair usually cost? A: Most fixes are between $100 and $300, depending on the issue. Q: Can I fix my stove myself? A: You can try basic stuff like cleaning or checking the breaker, but leave gas or wiring issues to the pros. Q: Is it cheaper to repair or replace? A: It depends. Small repairs are usually cheaper. But if the fix costs over half the price of a new stove, replacement is a better deal. Q: How do I know if it’s safe to keep using my stove? A: If you smell gas, see sparks, or it keeps shutting off—stop using it and call for help right away. Q: Do you offer free estimates? A: Many good repair companies do, or at least give you an upfront quote before they start. Need Help with Your Stove? Whether you’re thinking about fixing it or ready to shop for something new, our friendly team can help. We’ll take a look, give you honest advice, and get your kitchen back on track—fast. 👉 Call us today to schedule your inspection or repair! Read More: